Jews and the Tea Party Movement

general
December 1, 2012
Share:email print

Steven Windmueller

Galvanizing support over the past couple of election cycles, the Tea Party consists of a number of groups that have coalesced around a shared ideology: The Tea Party is an American populist political movement…. It endorses reduced government spending, opposition to taxation, in varying degrees, reduction of the national debt and federal budget deficit, and adherence to an originalist interpretation of the United States Constitution.”1 The Tea Party movement grew out of the history of American conservatism. More directly, it drew on the popularist tradition framed in late-19th- and early-20th-century America, where groups sought to redefine the respective roles of government and citizen. Today, there are four Senators and 62 Representatives affiliated with the Tea Party. Additional members of Congress identify with the movement and its ideas but have not formally joined the Tea Party Caucus, founded in 2010 and chaired by Congresswoman Michele Bachmann of Minnesota.

Are Jews involved in this movement in any significant way? There is anecdotal and some preliminary statistical evidence, based on a 2010 Pew Research Center study, that while American Jews by and large remain liberal, there is a small subset of Jews that, while not necessarily identifying with the Tea Party, express strong support for Tea Party ideas —  specifically, their thoughts on economic and social issues.2 Among the economic elements, the size and performance of government and with reference to the social indicators, same-sex marriage, abortion, and gun ownership.

Freelance writer Bill Berkowitz, who has monitored right-wing movements, confirmed that “There is no doubt that there are Jews involved with the Tea Party movements.” But given the group’s posters (one depicts tax money disappearing into a funnel with a Jewish Star of David on it) and comments heard at its events, Berkowitz suggests that “[If] Tea Party organizers are as politically savvy as some of its Religious Right forebears, it might try to tamp down its more virulent anti-Semitic participants while at the same time keeping an eye out for a handful of charismatic Jewish personalities to point to as Tea Party allies.”3

A 2011 study I headed surveyed a cohort of about 2,300 Jewish voters and showed some 880 individuals who identified the Tea Party platform as “refreshing.”4 The research affirmed a political division among American Jews; especially among Republican Jews, differences in values and policy ideas about what is important to Republican Jewish voters was observed. The research also noted the growing divide of discourse between Jewish liberals and conservatives.

Findings confirm that the more religiously conservative or traditional a person is in his or her practice or belief, the more likely that that individual would resonate to the views and values of the Tea Party movement.

Two measures examined within the Pew study and replicated in my research confirmed that Tea Party advocates adopt a conservative approach to the economy and tend to take socially conservative positions. Tea Party backers also heavily endorse the rights of gun owners. Jews are politically more complex than simple party labels. There has always been a small cohort of Jews who have endorsed libertarian ideas. Now, not only has this group felt more empowered, but also other Jewish voters fearful about their financial future and that of the nation have found common cause with the Tea Party ideology. As Jews have become more deeply embedded in the mainstream of American society, their politics now emulate, to a greater degree, the diversity of ideas that define the broader culture.

Yet, as Washington, D.C. journalist James Besser reported, quoting Fred Zeidman, a longtime Jewish Republican leader in Texas, “The idea of the Tea Parties scares the hell out of the Jewish community, and I can’t tell you it’s unjustifiable in some cases. There are some candidates out there that are clearly unqualified.”5

While it is difficult to calculate the strength of Jewish involvement with the Tea Party, there may be a growing base of political interest in the economic and social principles of this movement.6

Judaism and American liberalism are understood to be compatible: Why not also Judaism and conservatism? American Jews want to feel that their Jewish identity is aligned with their political passions. As some begin to question the size and direction of government, and, more directly, specific social policies, they are finding themselves outside the liberal community and looking for a better fit. The neo-isolationism of some Tea Party ideologues, though, would run counter to the intense commitment that binds many Jews — especially within the Republican ranks — to the pro-Israel agenda. Whether this movement’s foreign policy ideas and
social extremism serve to drive a wedge between Tea Party activists and conservative Jewish voters, remains to be seen.

1 http://tea-party-news.android.informer.com

2 Scott Clement, “The Tea Party, Religion and Social Issues,” Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life, February 23, 2011

3 http://www.truth-out.org/buzzflash/commentary/item/8640-the-tea-party-movements-jewish-problem

4 ejewishphilanthropy.com/survey-confirms-the-depth-of-the-political-divide-among-jewish-voters/

5 http://www.thejewishweek.com/news/national/jewish_republicans_seen_edge_about_tea_party

6 http://www.truth-out.org/buzzflash/commentary/item/8640-the-tea-party-movements-jewish-problem

Share:email print

6 Comments

  1. I find it unusual that the Jewish would want to associate with people who are angry, hateful and certainly do not represent the “tax less, spend less” ideology the TP claim. There are numerous undertones and direct words of racism, sexism, despise for the poor, disabled, elderly, and those who are struggling. Take a look at their website or reports on them from the New York Times.

    It seems that the classy and sophisticated people the Jewish are, they wouldn’t want to associate with such a group.

    Posted by
    Sun
  2. There are two TEA Parties which meet in the suburbs of Chicago adjacent to Skokie. Skokie is the home of the Illinois Holocaust Museum and was known as Chicago’s most Jewish suburb for many years.

    Large numbers of those who attend are Jewish including some of the organizers.

    The wife of Illinois TEA Party favorite, Joe Walsh, is Jewish.

    Congressman Walsh was the guest speaker at one of their events and Congressman Walsh drew a huge crowd.

    A Jewish Pediatrician, who lives not far from Skokie, was the TEA Party favorite, running for State Senate as a Republican.

    Posted by
    PA1974
  3. I’ve been attending TEA Party meetings in 3 different states and I’ve never met anyone who was angry or hateful or who despised the poor, disabled, the elderly or the disabled.

    Well there was an angry person who attended once, but she turned out to be an angry Democratic operative who only came to be critical and write a nasty letter the editor of the local paper.

    Now about the New York Times. During the recent political season I was interviewed by one their reporters twice, and both times their reporters did not write what I said.

    If you really want to know how loving and caring TEA Party folks are, come visit us sometime.

    Shabbot Shalom!

    Posted by
    PA1974
  4. I am Jewish and a leader in our local Tea Party. We have other Jewish members, but most of the Jews here are too Red to participate in our tiny synagogue. The other nearby Jewish group is so left wing it’s hard to participate, left wing dogma and Judaism are the same for them. All our Tea Party members are very pro Israel. American Jews have to realize that the probably only thing to save the USA is a third or fourth Great Awakening, which must be Christian. While the anti-Semitism on the fringe of that is alarming, it is in the interest of the Jewish people and of all humanity for the USA to prosper. I don’t want to live in a world where the two major powers are China and the Muslim Brotherhood. My brother has disowned me for my beliefs.

    Posted by
    oldsoul
  5. I would like to add to my above post that I like being with people of faith as most of my fellow Tea Party members are. Jews seem to forget that the Republicans favored the establishment of Israel while the Democrats didn’t. Read Paul Johnson about what an anti-Semite Roosevelt was.

    Posted by
    oldsoul
  6. I agree with oldsoul. Nothing frustrates me more that the co-opting of Judaism by the left and subservience to the Democrats. Any opposing view in my congregation is met with attack and ridicule. I find less anti-semitism in the Tea Party than elsewhere in the US. In Democrat circles it masquerades as anti-Netanyahu or pro-Palestinian. Read “Herbert Hoover and the Jews”.

    Posted by
    mmb7982
Sh’ma does its best to present a multitude of perspectives on the topics that it presents, and promotes the active participation of its readers on its website and social media pages. In keeping with this, Sh’ma is committed to creating a safe and open space for its readers to voice their opinions in a respectful manner. Disagreement on subject matter is encouraged, but Sh’ma does not tolerate personal attacks or inappropriate language. Sh’ma reserves the right to remove any and all postings that do not fit the criteria outlined herein.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>