Guest Blog Post: In response to David Makovsky’s “A History of Hatred”

April 25, 2012
Share:email print


David Makovsky suggests (“A History of Hatred”, Sh’ma 42/689, April 2012) that the small group of “Price Tag” hooligans are “the closest inheritor of the Sicarii mantle” that “it is possible they are enjoying the tacit support of a wider group” and they must be stood up to “just as [is done] with Palestinian terrorism.” Makovsky is not only misleading his readers but is engaging in the very sinat chinim he rails against.  For example, no one has been found guilty or even charged with the crime of mosque-torching.

All the representative bodies of the Jewish residents in Judea and Samaria (Yesha) have consistently condemned the reckless, irresponsible criminal actions that were carried out under the “Price Tag” label.  Dany Dayan, Naftali Bennet, Elyakim HaEtzni, Pinchas Wallerstein and others are on record, in media interviews and op-ed articles.  Moreover, after the last outburst, “Price Tag” activity has disappeared.  Do rabbis, educators and public figures need to do more?  Yes, surely so. But Makovsky’s intimation, which would permit the entire camp of Jews living in Yesha to be stained and besmirched, is itself a bit of internecine warfare, semantic, true, but nevertheless intended to support an attack on a “wider group” that certainly is not involved and has worked against the phenomenon.

A second disturbing frame of argument employed by Makovsky is comparing Arab terror activity with “Price Tag” operations. That is wrong.  Makovsky knows that Jewish law can turn on the size of an olive. These kids are not modern-day sicarii.  In fact, I would suggest that the amount of soccer stadium ruffians are many more in absolute numbers here in Israel and have caused damage to life, limb and property which might even equal that of the “Price Tag” teenagers. I am not relieving anyone of responsibility but simple providing some perspective which was lacking in Makovsky’s piece which could justify a claim of “we Jews have the Price Taggers and the Arabs have Hamas/Fatah/Islamic Jihad.”  This would be immoral because it would, and it could, allow anti-Zionists and others to point a finger of blame which should not be done.

The over 350,000 Jewish resident in Judea and Samaria have established institutions of society, social welfare, education, culture, health, immigrant absorption, science, security and politics.  We include voters from Meretz to Shas. We have a problem and it is being dealt with. Hopefully, though not yet under control, it is being treated as best as we now can, given the background of the sometimes irrational actions of the military government here as well as the absurdities emanating from the Defense Ministry (among other things, I am referring to the latest house purchase in Hebron).

Yisrael Medad

Share:email print
Related Topics:

Yisrael Medad, an American-born Israeli commentator, has lived in Shiloh since 1981. He is director of educational programming at the Menachem Begin Heritage Center in Jerusalem and blogs at

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>